Global Dashboard

Swine flu cooked up in a lab (updatedx8) David Steven

April 26, 2009 | More on Global system | 5 comments

From 9/11 truther mission control, Infowars, comes stunning news: “deadly swine flu… was cooked up in a lab.”

Yes – the first swine flu conspiracy theories are hitting the Internets, providing a rare opportunity to view these numb skull paranoids as they struggle to assemble a few fragments of information into a suitably cunning plot.

Here’s how it goes:

Evidence: The flu virus is reported to combine “genetic material from pigs, birds and humans in a way researchers have not seen before.” Implication: the virus was probably deliberately released.

Evidence:  ”In all U.S. cases, the victims had no contact with any pigs.” ImplicationPigs are evil… er they caught it from other people… er pigs never had anything to do with it.

Evidence: A public health official says: “This strain of swine influenza that’s been cultured in a laboratory is something that’s not been seen anywhere [before].” Implication: The poor guy wasn’t referring to standard identification techniques, but letting slip vital details of a dastardly scheme. WE TOLD YOU IT WAS DELIBERATELY RELEASED.

Evidence: The world has huge stock piles of Tamiflu. Top globalists and Bilderberg members like George Shultz, Lodewijk J.R. de Vink and former Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld” have a financial interest in Tamiflu. Implication: THEY’RE BEHIND THE ATTACK.

Evidence: The 1976 swine flu scare didn’t add up to much. Implication: RUMSFELD WAS BEHIND THAT TOO.

Now I am sure the story will become more polished as additional information is available to be distorted. But remember. This is how it started. And this is how little evidence these cretins need to start spinning their fantasies…

Update: Mike Adams, editor of Natural News, chimes in with one of the great rhetorical questions of all time:

Could world governments, spooked by the prospect of radical climate change caused by over-population of the planet, have assembled a super-secret task force to engineer and distribute a super virulent strain of influenza designed to “correct” the human population (and institute global Martial Law)?

Er – probably not Mike.

Update II: OMYGOODGOD  the plot is really thickening… As Dan O’Huiginn points out in the comments, the spiciest nutjob theory is that swine flu was “a high tech assassination attempt on President Obama.” Robert Wenzel is one of many pushing this fantasy:

During President Obama’s recent trip to Mexico, Obama was received at Mexico’s anthropology museum in Mexico City by Felipe Solis, a distinguished archaeologist who died the following day from symptoms similar to flu…

Clearly, if the man died the next day, he was highly contagious when Obama met him, and could have infected Obama easily. That, it appears, he didn’t infect Obama could just be a matter of luck for Obama.

Some reports say Solis died of a heart attack (an obvious cover up), others that he may have been an innocent victim of the flu (what idiot would believe that?).  Wenzel knows better:

They keep Obama in a bubble. I see the way he travels around D.C. I would think it’s pretty near impossible for a gunman to get to Obama (unless it is someone already around him who has a gun– a guard losing it type thing) But sophisticated planners, who can do the hit through a third person who will have the virus and will be able to pass through security, while the real perpetrators are not even at the scene, that could only be executed by very serious players.

Keep this in mind. The population of Mexico City, where Obama was greeted by Solis, is roughly 8.8 million people. If we assume all the 1,000 reported cases of the flu in Mexico are in Mexico City, the odds of any specific person in Mexico City having the virus is .0125%. And this guy ends up greeting the President, when he is highly contagious? It’s investigation time.

Update III: Now we’ve got a witness!!! Granted we don’t even know his name, but the conspiracy case is beginning to look pretty watertight:

Guys, you’re the only ones i can tell about this. Be careful who you inform.

I’m a trucker with a stellar record, and I’ve been getting bigger and bigger transport jobs from the government over the years. The job’s been good to me, as I do not have to interact with anyone when I’m on the job, and most people stay away from me because they assume I’m dumb as a sack of bricks. I don’t mind, since I don’t like people.

Two weeks ago I finished transporting some biohazard-labeled sealed boxes to the Pentagon. After an armed escort met me at the loading dock, they told me to wait in truck until someone arrived with a check. These people weren’t the govt workers I knew and interacted with regularly, so they didn’t know that I wasn’t the average retarded truck driver. They didn’t think I had enough curiosity to wander around a bit, as I always do.

I saw the boxes from my truck opened and lying discarded in a room right by the dock. The contents were gone, but a sheet of paper with Pentagon letterhead was still lying inside. Half a page down was the heading “H1N1 phase I – probability of success by epicenter.” At the top of the list was Mexico City, followed by Los Angeles, New York, Houston, and Singapore(?). Not being retarded, I remembered enough of what I read to jar my memory when the first reports came out. Wherever you are, be careful – there are powers and interests here far more dangerous than you imagine.

Update IV: Via Twitter, Mark Borkowski tunes in. ‘Who?’ you ask. Mark Borkowski. A man whose ‘face is known to millions’, who TV producers turn to whenever they need ‘authoritative comment on scandals, celebrity and the media itself’, and the guy who Eddie Izzard, Graham Norton, Joan Rivers, Macaulay Culkin, Sir Cliff Richard, Shirley Bassey, and the Bolshoi Ballet rely on to protect their various reputations.

Borkowski (who I met once, and is a thoroughly nice guy) is working on “a hunch that the swine flu panic iis [sic] stirred up by a US PR company to help the development and manufacture of a dodgy vaccine.” And yes, he’s deadly serious. When questioned, he reveals that “some dark uber lord with a pharma account” is behind it all. Will keep you in touch as the PR legend’s investigation develops…

Update V: The mysterious trucker popped up on March 30 in a slightly different guise in a call to radio show The Power Hour. Unfortunately the caller can’t reveal where she got her information: “What I am saying has already put me in danger.”

YouTube Preview Image

Update VI: I was naive in my initial premise that swine flu conspiracy theories were born de novo over the weekend. Of course, these memes have been incubating throughout the period in which avian flu has been in the news. The new theories also grow from old anxieties about government-sponsored vaccination programmmes. More on this later, maybe. 

For now, and as a last update to this post, many of the conspiracy theorists believe that the 1918/1919 pandemic was the result of a US biowarfare programme. Why? Because the Nazis said so:

In 1948 Heinrich Mueller, the former head of the Gestapo, told his CIA Interrogator that the most devastating plague in human history was man-made. 

He was referring to the influenza pandemic of 1918-1919 that infected 20% of the world’s population and killed between 60 and 100 million people. This is roughly three times as many as were killed and wounded in World War One, and is comparable to WWII losses, yet this modern plague has slipped down the memory hole.

Mueller said the flu started as a US army bacteriological warfare weapon that somehow infected US army ranks at Camp Riley KS in March 1918, and spread around the world. He says that it “got out of control” but we cannot discount the horrible possibility that the “Spanish Flu” was a deliberate elite depopulation measure, and that it could be used again. Researchers have found connections between it and the “Bird Flu.”

Update VII: OK -a few more updates. Why are only Mexicans dying? Because the ‘weaponized virus’ has been deliberately engineered to target Hispanics.

Update VIII: Now it’s settling down, the key ingredients in the conspiracy ‘theory seem to be:

Governments have form - most big epidemics are government-sponsored attacks. 1918/19 flu, foot and mouth, HIV – all weaponized viruses.

Governments have motive - the New World Order is engaged in a war with humanity. An epidemic – with associated ‘dark winter’ as basic services are withdrawn – will allow globalists to make their move, creating world government etc.

Business has motive too – this is a chance to sell lots of vaccines and anti-virals. Plus businesses are also controlled by globalists and are committed to the New World Order.

Swine flu is clearly weaponized - the obvious signs are (i) an unusual mix of human, pig and bird viruses – couldn’t happen in nature; (ii) simultaneous release across multiple sites – too quick for ‘ordinary’ transmission; (iii) various scientists etc. have confirmed the virus is manmade, though they’re being hushed up; (iv) eye witnesses are desperately trying to get information out about the plot, at real danger to their lives.

Something very bad is going to happen – Four things could be going on, in ascending levels of scariness: (i) This is a ‘beta test’ – a trial balloon. (ii) This is a pretext to mass vaccinate people with a poisonous vaccine. (iii) The take over by the globalists is beginning. Prepare for a world police state; (iv) A massive cull of the population is underway (80% or so) – to create a world that’s much easier to control. 


5 comments »


  1. Don’t forget the theory that Obama met one of the early victims. Therefore it must have been an unsuccessful attack on him.

    [can't be bothered to hunt down a link. It's out there somewhere]


  2. Oh yeah. And the wtc’s attacks were issued from within the pentagon. This is old news. There’s a Bad Guy, sitting in a shadowy room full of computers, and responsible for every situation out there.


  3. Four things could be going on, in ascending levels of scariness: (i) This is a ‘beta test’ – a trial balloon. (ii) This is a pretext to mass vaccinate people with a poisonous vaccine. (iii) The take over by the globalists is beginning. Prepare for a world police state; (iv) A massive cull of the population is underway (80% or so) – to create a world that’s much easier to control.

    I think that point (ii) could be interesting if you’ve already watched the first part of zeitgeist where there’s a part of an interview to Aaron Russo where he claims that Nick Rockefeller told him that he knew about the events of 9/11. In that interview he also says that he wants a world police state where everyone gets chipped with a microchip. This microchip was designed to fit into a vaccin and I think that it was even designed. Maybe he wanted to kill obama too…


  4. I suppose that the thousands of factor eight contamination where the Red Cross knowingly gave “tainted” blood to their victims to die of AIDS and Hep C never happened. I suppose the corporate media never outright lies or exaggerates. Millions die from the flu every year.
    This could be a scenario for the government to set up some phase of a martial law type police state. There are lots of malevolent people in government as history teaches us. To not even question the possibility that this hyped up dilemna was hatched in a lab is irresponsible. Vaccination is big business, and crisis benefits a select few.


  5. First of all we weren’t trying to kill the president we were tying to thin out Mexico a bit to ease immigration and make it more viable to move US borders south more. (Mexico owes the US money they will never be able to repay, so we’re just reposessing their property. If we can get them past panama border control will be cake.

    Secondly, when we deal with our deadly engineered bio toxins the people who do R&D and would have target information NEVER leave the secure labs with anything other than their clothes.

    Third, we never ship our deadly engineered bio toxins to any major state or government facility as they’re all under constant surveillance from locals, air/sat photography, and foreign agents just waiting for something like this.
    Instead we ship them to “cover organizations” Called something like “Randaux Biofuel Reasearch Inc.”

    And finally, under no circumstances do we ship anything like this via a standard commercial truck like. We just have one of our people do it (There are special protocols that have to be observed in the event you get pulled over by the police and/or if there’s an accident etc,..Then if they talk they knwo that their family ends up dead so we don’t need to worry about thinks like this article.

08/02 18:14 Cathy Ashton's speech to the 46th Munich Security Conference "We must mobilise all our levers of influence — political, economic, plus civil and military crisis management tools — in support of a single political strategy. "
08/02 16:00 Cabinet Office publishes quango figures Civil Service Network: "spending by non-departmental bodies reached £46.5bn in 2008/09, up from £37bn in 2006/7,"
07/02 18:36 Ashton names team to advise on EEAS | European Voice Full list of the senior officials who'll be advising Cathy Ashton on the EU's new diplomatic service
05/02 10:27 My heart refuses to race to this cross-Channel love-in | The Guardian Martin Kettle: "A combination of cultural mistrust and divergent national interest means it [Anglo-French defence cooperation] isn't going to happen."
04/02 11:52 France and Germany to unveil 10-year plan | EUobserver Merkel and Sarkozy "set to unveil their own economic and political strategy document, the 'Franco-German Agenda 2020' "
02/02 13:49 Plane Crash Survival Guide You're six miles up, alone and falling without a parachute. Though the odds are long, a small number of people have found themselves in similar situations—and lived to tell the tale.
02/02 11:34 Digital doomsday: the end of knowledge - New Scientist If our civilisation runs into trouble, like all others before it, how much of our current knowledge would survive?
02/02 09:47 China Records Its Climate Actions By Copenhagen Accord Deadline Useful breakdown of China's domestic climate and energy programs
01/02 14:14 Africa's continental divide: land disputes / The Christian Science Monitor - CSMonitor.com "Land is at the core of almost everything. It's the means for livelihood. It's power; it's status; it's security. It's the most powerful asset people have."
01/02 13:47 African Union picks new leader as Gadhafi exits - CNN.com Malawian President is new head of the AU
31/01 13:11 Afraid of the Dark in Afghanistan Torture, it appears, continues to be commonplace in Afghanistan.
31/01 10:53 Why did Lady Ashton take the EU's foreign policy job? | The Economist "People across the whole EU foreign policy machine are asking the same question: why did she take this huge job, when her instinct seems to be to make it as low key as possible?"
31/01 10:51 Energy and climate in Obama’s SOTU speech | FT Energy Source | FT.com Climate did get a few mentions, contrary to some expectations - but cap-and-trade didn't
31/01 10:51 Peak oil: Oh yes it is. Oh no it isn’t. Etc. | FT Energy Source | FT.com What people said about peak oil at the Davos energy security session
31/01 10:44 The Politics of Well-Being: Facing death stoically Interview with a US Marine Corps officer who served in Afghanistan and Iraq, by GD's Jules Evans
27/01 22:29 Climate change: Chinese adviser calls for open mind on causes | Environment | guardian.co.uk China's most senior negotiator on climate change said today he was keeping an open mind on whether global warming was man-made or the result of natural cycles.
27/01 22:16 Fox most trusted news channel in US, poll shows | World news | guardian.co.uk Almost half of all Americans surveyed in the poll of 1,151 registered voters said they trusted Fox News, as compared to the 39% for CNN
26/01 22:06 British Newspapers Make Things Up | Psychology Today Why all British newspapers are tabloids, says Satoshi Kanazawa
26/01 19:28 The Press Association: Davos security boss kills himself The police commander in charge of security for the Davos World Economic Forum has killed himself on the eve of the conference
25/01 11:24 The UK's world role: Great Britain's greatness fixation | The Guardian "No longer the greatest. Just one great among others. Good enough ought to be good enough. The people get it. If only the politicians did too."
25/01 11:22 Pedestrian footsteps, converted into energy - Springwise "Each rubber slab from UK-based Pavegen Systems gets depressed by about 5 mm each time it gets stepped on. Using just that small movement, it can convert the kinetic energy used into electricity"
19/01 19:14 No way to run a government 177 members of Obama's administration are still not confirmed. Many of them are destined for key foreign policy jobs. It's a monumentally stupid way to run a government.
19/01 11:35 Eurozone seeks political voice at G20 | FT Tony Barber: there is a "determination [among] European policymakers to boost the eurozone’s international profile and strengthen its internal cohesion under the provisions of [Lisbon]"
15/01 14:59 Rory Stewart's awfully big adventure | Guardian Stewart: "The world isn't one way or ­another. Things can be changed very, very rapidly and can be changed by someone with sufficient confidence, sufficient knowledge and sufficient ­authority."
14/01 17:19 President Obama, the CIA and the Master of the Cover-Up - Truthout "In relying on those individuals who have circled the wagons to protect themselves and the agency, the president has deprived himself of an opportunity to understand intelligence failures"
13/01 23:40 How to reform the British Foreign Office | FT Mark Malloch-Brown: "A modern diplomat needs to be an alliance builder and often a social campaigner, not a solitary John Bull."
12/01 10:36 Nine meals from anarchy | Guardian Andrew Simms: "When Gordon Brown meets Cobra, the civil contingencies committee, this week, item one should be the transition to a more sustainable food and energy system.."
12/01 09:48 The tug of war over Britain’s economic policy | FT Philip Stephens on the shifting relationship between politicians and the Bank of England
11/01 15:24 Meg Whitman's climate change strategy - LATimes.com In what may be a risky political move, the GOP candidate for governor of California has come out strongly against the state's law on regulating greenhouse gas emissions.
08/01 11:57 New Treaty for EU but Same Jostling for Power - NYTimes.com Madrid said its EU Presidency is transitional and will be the last of its kind. But some analysts worry that Spain’s assertive stance will provoke turf wars and set a precedent for other nations to. […]
07/01 18:39 Rahm Emanuel's White House future bleak - NYPOST.com "DC clairvoyants say Rahm Emanuel will leave as President Obama's chief-of-staff in the not-too-distant future" - Valerie Jarrett suggested as front runner to replace
07/01 16:22 APAC 2020 | The decade ahead Useful hub site covering Asian countries and regional issues
07/01 11:01 As USAID awaits its fate, Clinton lays out new U.S. development agenda | The Cable Josh Rogin: "Clinton has made it clear that she wants the elevation of the development mission to be a key part of her legacy"
05/01 17:31 Hackers Attack Ahmadinejad’s Web site - The Lede Blog - NYTimes.com “Someone seems to have had their way with Ahmadinejad’s web servers.”
04/01 22:30 FT.com / Gideon Rachman - America is losing the free world Four of the biggest and most strategically important democracies in the developing world – Brazil, India, South Africa and Turkey – are increasingly at odds with US foreign policy.
04/01 17:54 Afghanistan: What Could Work - The New York Review of Books Rory Stewart assesses Obama's poker face
04/01 13:56 Smiths lifted by airport scanner surge after failed Christmas bombing | Business Signs of the times - following attempted terrorist attack in US, world's biggest manufacturer of airport detection devices sees shares up 3.7 per cent as soon as markets open
04/01 13:33 FT.com / Europe - Russia stops oil shipments to Belarus Hey, I think I already saw this movie
04/01 11:05 Bruce Schneier on TSA Absurdity and the Need for Resilience | The Atlantic Schneier discusses aviation security and our response to terrorism with Jeffrey Goldberg
02/01 23:33 Why Twitter Will Endure - NYTimes.com “There have been cool Web sites that go in and out of fashion and then there have been open standards that become plumbing... Twitter is looking more and more like plumbing.”
Source: GLOABL Dashboard Reading List Pipes
Articles & Publications
Time to Stop Betting the House: a response to the FSA

Report by David Steven in response to the FSA’s Mortgage Market Review
Download Report

Confronting the Long Crisis of Globalization: Risk, Resilience and International Order

Brookings Institution report by Alex Evans, Bruce Jones and David Steven on how globalisation could fail – and how it could be made more resilient. Published to coincide with the 40th anniversary World Economic Forum in Davos.

Hitting Reboot – where next for climate after Copenhagen

Report by Alex Evans and David Steven analysing the post-Copenhagen context on climate change, including a proposed 12 point action plan. Written for the Brookings Institution / NYU Center on International Cooperation Managing Global Insecurity programme.

Climate Change and Hunger: Responding to the challenge

World Food Programme report on the state of the science on what climate change means for hunger, plus policy recommendations. Authored by IPCC Impacts Chair Martin Parry with Mark Rosengrant, Tim Wheeler and Global Dashboard’s Alex Evans (December 2009)

Scarcity, security and institutional reform

Presentation by Alex Evans to a seminar organised for the UN Department of Political Affairs by the Geneva Centre for Security Policy (August 2009)

The Resilience Doctrine

Article on risk and resilience by Alex Evans and David Steven – part of a special in World Politics Review on risk and resilience in a globalized age (July 2009)

An Institutional Architecture for Climate Change

Report by Alex Evans and David Steven exploring the future international institutional requirements for managing climate change, and including three scenarios for climate institutions between now and 2030. Commissioned by the UK Department for International Development. (May 2009)

Risks and Resilience in the New Global Era

Article by Alex Evans and David Steven exploring resilience as a political agenda – part of a special edition of Renewal on the transformation of foreign policy (February 2009)

A Tale of Two Cities

Climate and cities think piece, co-authored by David Steven and the British Council’s Peter Upton (29 January 2009)

The Feeding of the Nine Billion

Chatham House pamphlet by Alex Evans on how scarcity issues will shape the outlook for global food production, and the actions that policymakers need to take at the international level and in developing countries to ensure food security in the 21st century

2009 – A Year for International Reform

Paper by David Steven, presented to “Reforming International Institutions – Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century,” a conference organized by the United Nations University and the British Embassy in Tokyo (Jan 2009).

Food prices: what next?

Speech by Alex Evans at the Tomorrow Network (25 November 2008)

A Bretton Woods II Worthy of the Name

Paper by Alex Evans and David Steven on financial reform and wider multilateralism, published ahead of the G20 ‘Bretton Woods II’ Summit (November 2008).

The Future of Resilience

Speech by David Steven to RUSI Conference on UK Resilience (8 October 2008)

Towards a Theory of Influence

Chapter by Alex Evans and David Steven in the Foreign & Commonwealth Office publication, ‘Engagement: public diplomacy in a globalised world’ (July 2008).
Download Chapter

Multilateralism for an Age of Scarcity

Draft report by Alex Evans exploring multilateral system reforms needed in order to manage resource scarcity issues more effectively. The final version will be published in early 2010 (July 2008)

Scarcity issues and conflict in Africa

Speech by Alex Evans at UK Parliament (8 July 2008)

A Low Carbon World – Pathways to a Global Deal

Speech by David Steven at the UNU G8 Symposium (4 July 2008)

Climate, scarcity and multilateralism

Speech by Alex Evans to United Nations Association UK (7 June 2008)

The new public diplomacy and Afghanistan

Speech by David Steven to the UK Defence Academy’s Advanced Research and Assessment Group seminar on Strategic Communications, Public Diplomacy and Afghanistan (4 June 2008).

Technology and Public Diplomacy

Speech by David Steven to the University of Westminster Symposium on Transformational Public Diplomacy (30 April 2008).

Rising Food Prices: Drivers and Implications for Development

Briefing paper by Alex Evans, published through Chatham House’s food programme (April 2008).

Looking Forward: how do we build resilience?

Speech by David Steven to RUSI Conference on Critical National Infrastructure (16 April 2008).

Shooting the Rapids: multilateralism and global risks

Paper by Alex Evans and David Steven, commissioned by Gordon Brown and presented to heads of state at the Progressive Governance Summit (April 2008).

Beyond a Zero-Sum Game on Climate Change

Chapter by Alex Evans and David Steven, as part of the British Council’s Transatlantic Network 2020 book ‘Talking Trans-Atlantic’ (March 2008).

From Bali to Copenhagen: towards an endgame for global climate policy?

Article by Alex Evans for the Environmental Policy & Law Journal (January 2008).

Climate Change: The State of the Debate

Report by Alex Evans and David Steven, written for the London Accord (December 2007).

The Post-Kyoto Bidding War: bringing developing countries into the fold

New paper by Alex Evans on climate policy after 2012 from the Center on International Cooperation (October 2007).

Alternative CSR: the Foreign & Commonwealth Office

Chapter on the FCO from Manchester University Press’s Alternative Comprehensive Spending Review, by David Steven (September 2007).

Fixing the UK’s Foreign Policy Apparatus: A Memo to Gordon Brown

Note by Alex Evans and David Steven about how to restructure the UK’s foreign policy system in order to manage trans-boundary global risks better (April 2007).

Evaluation and the New Public Diplomacy

Talk given by David Steven at the Wilton Park conference: The Future of Public Diplomacy. Focuses on strategies to drive public diplomacy to the heart of the foreign policy armoury (March 2007).

Articles and Publications

YouTube Preview Image

Carne Ross on how the Chilcot Inquiry blew it with Blair | 2 Comments

YouTube Preview Image

Charlie Brooker explains the news | Comment

YouTube Preview Image

We can forget about cap and trade now | Comments Off

YouTube Preview Image

What Obama should be watching today | Comments Off

YouTube Preview Image

Is France a country? | 4 Comments

More What we're watching

Key Posts
Time to Stop Betting the House

Today, I launch a new paper on risk and resilience in the UK housing market. The report calls for a fundamental shift in the way in which the UK mortgage market is regulated and the how it operates.
The paper is published by the Long Finance Foundation, which is a counter to [...]

Confronting the Long Crisis of Globalization

Brookings Institution report by Alex Evans, Bruce Jones and David Steven on how globalisation could fail – or be made more resilient. Published to coincide with the 40th anniversary World Economic Forum in Davos.

The best news on climate change for months. Maybe.

Bono endorses contraction and convergence – potentially kicking off a major (and long overdue) strategic rethink on climate change among NGOs and civil society

Copenfailure: a first analysis

A very rough first analysis of the Copenhagen Outcome, two hours after the summit finished.

How we talk about climate change

We’re kidding ourselves if we think that “green collar jobs” will persuade people to take serious action on climate change. A deeper narrative is required.

The window of opportunity on scarcity issues starts to close (updated x3)

With oil and food prices already back to July 07 levels, have policymakers missed the window of opportunity to take action when prices eased after the credit crunch?

The Pentagon’s new spiritual fitness programme

Exclusive interview with Brigadier-General Rhonda Cornum on the Pentagon’s new spiritual fitness training programme, which uses Stoic techniques.

Read more » | Comments Off

Down with collapse!

Enough already with all the talk of ‘collapse’, ‘descent’, ‘powerdown’. How about talking about ‘renewal’, ‘transformation’, ‘renaissance’?