Global Dashboard

Who did it? Mark Weston

March 2, 2009 | More on Africa, Conflict and security | One comment

Just a final word at the end of a turbulent day on the assassination of Guinea-Bissau’s two most powerful men, the President Joao Bernardo Vieira and the army chief of staff, General Tagme Na Waie.  It seems pretty likely that troops close to the General were responsible for killing the President, in revenge for what they thought was a Vieira-backed plot to do away with his rival.

But the more interesting question is who killed Tagme Na Waie? Vieira is obviously the prime suspect, as he hated the General, who had accused him of involvement in the cocaine trade (many diplomats thought Tagme was also involved). Vieira had not shrunk from murder to get rid of political opponents during his first spell in charge of the country in the 1980s, and Tagme Na Waie himself blamed the presidential guard for an attempt on his life in January.

But an analyst who spoke to the Times today said the killing of the General bore the hallmarks of a hit by drug cartels.  South Americans using other Guineans (including possibly Vieira) to smooth their path through the country could have wanted to remove Tagme as he was getting in their way. This would tally with similar killings in Colombia and Mexico over the years, with one gang eliminating another’s key contacts or leaders.

But would the inevitable chaos provoked by such an action benefit the cartels? If they’d wanted chaos, surely they’d have chosen Liberia or Cote d’Ivoire rather than Guinea-Bissau as their transit point. Both those countries were or had just been at war when the Colombians arrived. Guinea-Bissau was stable by comparison. It is hard to see how turmoil helps the cartels, who, as John Robb said when I interviewed him recently, “want the maximum level of corruption and to be left alone, with bureaucratic apparatus geared towards helping them do business.” The dealers are, in the end, businessmen, and doing business will be infinitely more difficult if civil war breaks out.

Perhaps Tagme’s killers miscalculated, and assumed that Vieira would quickly be able to put a lid on any unrest that ensued from the murder.  If so (and even if they had no hand in either killing), might they now shift their operations to somewhere more stable – Senegal, maybe, or even Ghana?


One comment »


  1. Grim news. Hope the drug gangs don’t move into Ghana, it seems to be developing quite well as a country (from the perspective of my desk in Clapham, anyway).
    New issue with your article on drugs in West Africa is out soon, Ill send you a copy.

24/11 12:16 AIDS: Turning the screw some more | The Economist New infections have dropped globally by 17% since 2001 (even if Africa, infections are down 15%); and the total of AIDS-relateed deaths is down 10% in 5 years.
24/11 10:30 Chilcot Iraq Inquiry, day 1: best of the evidence - Times Online “I remember conversations with my French and Russian colleagues saying ’You know, if you don’t agree to this, where this is going’. And each time they always agreed three months too late.”
23/11 06:23 A Nobel Prize for Political Science | The Hindu Jorge Heine: "the analytical and methodological toolkit of economists is by no means the only one available to map out the road towards improving our comprehension of social problems. "
23/11 04:43 Could sovereign debt be the new subprime? | FT Gilian Tett: "as policymakers rush to implement reforms in response to one financial calamity, they are apt to create distortions that pave the way for the next disaster."
23/11 04:34 How much money is enough? | Guardian Robert Skidelsky: "The accumulation of wealth, which should be a means to the 'good life,' becomes an end in itself because it destroys many of the things that make life worth living."
22/11 02:55 IBM makes supercomputer significantly smarter than cat But working out how to use such a massive simulation proves difficult.
18/11 05:22 EU top jobs summit could drag on for days | EUobserver Cecilia Malmstrom, Swedish EU affairs minister: "I wouldn't say it's a complete mess, but there's no agreement still"
18/11 05:04 New Prospect poll: The rise of Britain’s liberal “twittering classes” | Prospect Magazine Twitterers in Britain have a "strongly liberal and civil libertarian bias".
18/11 05:02 Schneier on Security: Beyond Security Theater The incentives are lined up against the most effective responses to risk.
17/11 03:28 America’s First Cannabis Cafe Open - The Lede Blog - NYTimes.com Last Friday, the first coffee house in the United States allowing licensed users of medical marijuana to sit down and smoke, opened for business in Portland, Ore.
16/11 14:44 Modern Warfare 2 apparently nixed by Russian authorities | csmonitor.com Russian government less than happy about videogame's "portrayal of Russia’s armed forces as terrorists who invade the US and erect statues of dead terrorists in Washington"
15/11 08:49 BBC Radio 4 Programmes - Food Programme, 30th Anniversary On which GD's Alex Evans rambles on about feeding the nine billion
13/11 03:48 Senior Tories look for exit as Francis Maude compiles special adviser list - PR and Public Relations news - PR Week Cabinet Ministers will only get one special adviser each (rather than 2, as now) - focused only on policy, as all media special advisers will be based in No 10. That's the plan, anyway
13/11 03:36 Creative energy descent: Not a collapse, more like evolution | OurWorld 2.0 UNU's Brendan Barrett sets out an excellent discussion of what lies on the other side of the peak
12/11 11:41 French and Irish fall out over ‘box’ incident Sarkozy insulted. Major diplomatic incident brewing.
12/11 11:35 Member states failing to meet aid targets | European Voice Only five of the 27 EU member states are likely to meet their development aid targets for 2010.
12/11 11:31 Interview: Robert Skidelsky | New Statesman "I don't think there is a fiscal crisis. I think it's an invention", argues Keynes' biographer
12/11 09:35 China hacked Obama campaign's computers FBI told campaign: "You've got a problem. Somebody's trying to get inside your systems." McCain had same problem. Allegedly.
12/11 06:15 The 'Should We Stay Or Should We Go?' Matrix Where top US opinion-makers stand on the Afghanistan question.
12/11 04:12 Violence and Social Orders - Cambridge University Press Current cult reading among development nerds
12/11 04:12 December 2009: Craig Brown on Malcolm Gladwell | vanityfair.com As the FT's Clive Crook observes of this piece: perfect.
11/11 18:06 Gold - a six thousand year-old bubble - Willem Buiter The wonders, mysteries and evils of gold.
11/11 14:53 2012: The End Of The World? Whether or not you're interested in the 2012 apocalypse, this is a ravishing infographic.
11/11 13:04 Russian cannibal who ate his mother Apparently, the guy was given lighter sentence by judge who says 'he was starving, he needed to eat'.
11/11 11:29 Brazil pledges deep emission cuts in 'political gesture' to rich nations | Environment | guardian.co.uk Brazil offers 40% below 2020 business as usual scenario - though don't fall into the trap of comparing that with the EU's 30% offer (which is below 1990 rather than 2020 levels)
11/11 08:15 Millions left in the dark as massive power failure strikes Brazil - Times Online How critical infrastructure is vulnerable to climate impacts (in this case, a severe storm that uprooted trees and caused a massive hydro dam to go off-line)
11/11 08:14 Key oil figures were distorted by US pressure, says whistleblower | Environment | The Guardian Anonymous senior IEA officials say we're already in peak oil zone
11/11 04:06 You created this job, David Miliband. You should do it | Times Daniel Finkelstein: "The Lisbon treaty is your work as much as anyone’s. You pushed it through and you told everyone that it really mattered."
10/11 17:57 Expensive chips from Shrinky Dinks A wonderful tale of bodging.
10/11 05:51 Are we running out of oil? The world in energy statistics The amount of proven oil reserves awaiting to be exploited fell last year for the first time in a decade, according to the BP figures.
09/11 14:06 What’s Next for the Climate Bill? - Environmental Capital - WSJ After all the excitement last week in the Senate environment committee, is the real fun just starting for the climate bill?
09/11 14:04 Call White House, Ask for Barack - Thomas Friedman It is time for a radically new approach. And I mean radical. I mean something no U.S. administration has ever dared to do: Take down our “Peace-Processing-Is-Us” sign and just go home.
09/11 14:02 Miliband "definitely" out of High Rep race, possibly | Charlemagne's notebook | Economist.com David Miliband, according to several European socialist leaders, has “definitively” refused to put himself forwards. Really?
09/11 04:22 Tear down this wall! And save the planet | Times Mikhail Gorbachev: "The climate crisis is the new wall that divides us from our future"
08/11 05:18 Democrats claim big victory on health care Health care finally passes the House.
06/11 07:14 Normalisation of Deviance | London Review Blog Hugh Pennington on (un)acceptable risks
06/11 06:49 WBS: Food security risk: USA most stable, but India is “high risk” Warwick Business School produces new index of countries' food security risk
04/11 14:26 Shut… Down… Everything! Pandemic II and the Madagascar problem.
04/11 13:49 Iraq Swears by Bomb Detector U.S. Sees as Useless Iraqi forces are using what is basically a dousing stick to detect explosives. Seriously.
04/11 13:26 Top Dems: No Health Care Bill in 2009 Put that in your Copenhagen pipe and smoke it.
Source: GLOABL Dashboard Reading List Pipes
Articles & Publications
Scarcity, security and institutional reform

Presentation by Alex Evans to a seminar organised for the UN Department of Political Affairs by the Geneva Centre for Security Policy (August 2009)

The Resilience Doctrine

Article on risk and resilience – part of a special in World Politics Review on risk and resilience in a globalized age (July 2009)

An Institutional Architecture for Climate Change

Report exploring the future international institutional requirements for managing climate change, and including three scenarios for climate institutions between now and 2030. Commissioned by the UK Department for International Development. (May 2009)

Risks and Resilience in the New Global Era

Article exploring resilience as a political agenda – part of a special edition of Renewal on the transformation of foreign policy (February 2009)

A Tale of Two Cities

Climate and cities think piece, co-authored by David Steven and the British Council’s Peter Upton (29 January 2009)

The Feeding of the Nine Billion

Chatham House pamphlet by Alex Evans on how scarcity issues will shape the outlook for global food production, and the actions that policymakers need to take at the international level and in developing countries to ensure food security in the 21st century

2009 – A Year for International Reform

Paper by David Steven, presented to “Reforming International Institutions – Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century,” a conference organized by the United Nations University and the British Embassy in Tokyo (Jan 2009).

Food prices: what next?

Speech by Alex Evans at the Tomorrow Network (25 November 2008)

A Bretton Woods II Worthy of the Name

Paper by Alex Evans and David Steven on financial reform and wider multilateralism, published ahead of the G20 ‘Bretton Woods II’ Summit (November 2008).

The Future of Resilience

Speech by David Steven to RUSI Conference on UK Resilience (8 October 2008)

Towards a Theory of Influence

Chapter by Alex Evans and David Steven in the Foreign & Commonwealth Office publication, ‘Engagement: public diplomacy in a globalised world’ (July 2008).
Download Chapter

Scarcity issues and conflict in Africa

Speech by Alex Evans at UK Parliament (8 July 2008)

A Low Carbon World – Pathways to a Global Deal

Speech by David Steven at the UNU G8 Symposium (4 July 2008)

Climate, scarcity and multilateralism

Speech by Alex Evans to United Nations Association UK (7 June 2008)

The new public diplomacy and Afghanistan

Speech by David Steven to the UK Defence Academy’s Advanced Research and Assessment Group seminar on Strategic Communications, Public Diplomacy and Afghanistan (4 June 2008).

Technology and Public Diplomacy

Speech by David Steven to the University of Westminster Symposium on Transformational Public Diplomacy (30 April 2008).

Rising Food Prices: Drivers and Implications for Development

Briefing paper by Alex Evans, published through Chatham House’s food programme (April 2008).

Looking Forward: how do we build resilience?

Speech by David Steven to RUSI Conference on Critical National Infrastructure (16 April 2008).

Shooting the Rapids: multilateralism and global risks

Paper by Alex Evans and David Steven, commissioned by Gordon Brown and presented to heads of state at the Progressive Governance Summit (April 2008).

Beyond a Zero-Sum Game on Climate Change

Chapter by Alex Evans and David Steven, as part of the British Council’s Transatlantic Network 2020 book ‘Talking Trans-Atlantic’ (March 2008).

From Bali to Copenhagen: towards an endgame for global climate policy?

Article by Alex Evans for the Environmental Policy & Law Journal (January 2008).

Climate Change: The State of the Debate

Report by Alex Evans and David Steven, written for the London Accord (December 2007).

The Post-Kyoto Bidding War: bringing developing countries into the fold

New paper by Alex Evans on climate policy after 2012 from the Center on International Cooperation (October 2007).

Alternative CSR: the Foreign & Commonwealth Office

Chapter on the FCO from Manchester University Press’s Alternative Comprehensive Spending Review, by David Steven (September 2007).

Fixing the UK’s Foreign Policy Apparatus: A Memo to Gordon Brown

Note by Alex Evans and David Steven about how to restructure the UK’s foreign policy system in order to manage trans-boundary global risks better (April 2007).

Evaluation and the New Public Diplomacy

Talk given by David Steven at the Wilton Park conference: The Future of Public Diplomacy. Focuses on strategies to drive public diplomacy to the heart of the foreign policy armoury (March 2007).

Articles and Publications

YouTube Preview Image

Public diplomacy: Boris Johnson shows us how | Comment

YouTube Preview Image

Sarah Palin’s army | Comment

YouTube Preview Image

Hard landings | Comment

YouTube Preview Image

Cathy Ashton grilled on her agenda as EU Foreign Minister | Comment

YouTube Preview Image

Jared Diamond on collapse at TED | 1 Comment

More What we're watching

Key Posts
How we talk about climate change

We’re kidding ourselves if we think that “green collar jobs” will persuade people to take serious action on climate change. A deeper narrative is required.

The window of opportunity on scarcity issues starts to close (updated x3)

With oil and food prices already back to July 07 levels, have policymakers missed the window of opportunity to take action when prices eased after the credit crunch?

The Pentagon’s new spiritual fitness programme

Exclusive interview with Brigadier-General Rhonda Cornum on the Pentagon’s new spiritual fitness training programme, which uses Stoic techniques.

Read more » | Comments Off

Down with collapse!

Enough already with all the talk of ‘collapse’, ‘descent’, ‘powerdown’. How about talking about ‘renewal’, ‘transformation’, ‘renaissance’?

DFID: the department for conflict prevention?

DFID’s new White Paper is a big step forward on conflict prevention – but not necessarily for a joint approach across government

Read more » | Comments Off

The new protectionism

Leaders’ pledges not to go protectionist may be true as far as tariffs and quotas go – but take finance into account, and the rhetoric is harder to square with the reality

Pakistan, Kilcullen, Evans – a reply to David Miliband

Do we know what we’re trying to achieve in Pakistan?

Read more » | Comments Off

More on African land deals

Article on rich-country land acquisitions in Africa

Read more » | Comments Off